Baldur's Gate 3 Review
Our Verdict
Baldur's Gate 3 is gaming's greatest RPG — an unprecedented achievement in reactive storytelling, companion writing, and co-op design that redefines what the genre can be.
Combat: Tactical Depth
BG3's turn-based combat is D&D 5e faithfully realized. Initiative order, action economy (Action, Bonus Action, Reaction), and spell slot management create a tactical layer that rewards system knowledge. Environmental interactions — creating oil slicks and igniting them, pushing enemies off ledges, combining status effects — provide creative solutions the designers didn't anticipate. Honour Mode bosses add legendary actions that dramatically raise the difficulty ceiling.
Gameplay and World
The three Acts progress from the Wilderness and Underdark (Act 1) through the Shadow-Cursed Lands (Act 2) to the city of Baldur's Gate itself (Act 3). Each act has dozens of side quests, optional areas, and secret content that most players miss on their first run. The verticality of environments, the presence of both combat and dialogue solutions to most problems, and the reactivity of companion approval tracking create replay incentive across multiple playthroughs.
Story and Characters
The companion writing is the finest in any RPG. Astarion's trauma and redemption arc, Shadowheart's identity crisis, Karlach's heartbreaking timeline — each is a complete story with branching outcomes. The villain Cazador Szarr and the Elder Brain are genuinely menacing. The climactic Act 3 confrontations are among gaming's most spectacular set-pieces.
Verdict
Essential. Baldur's Gate 3 is gaming's new RPG benchmark and one of the greatest games ever made.
Pros & Cons
- Most reactive RPG narrative ever created — choices genuinely matter
- Companion writing is the finest in any RPG
- Four-player co-op transforms the experience
- D&D 5e implementation is faithful and deep
- Complete game at launch — no day-one DLC
- Act 3 (Baldur's Gate city) had performance issues at launch (improved significantly)
- The depth of systems can overwhelm newcomers to CRPGs
- Some companion questlines require specific, non-obvious choices to unlock
This review may contain affiliate links. Affiliate Disclosure